Executive Letter: CFPB Wins Section 1071 Case. Plaintiffs Plan to Appeal. WBA Continues to Fight!
By Rose Oswald Poels
Federal Judge Randy Crane made his decision last week in the much-anticipated case Texas Bankers Association v. CFPB, S.D. Tex., Docket No. 7:23-cd-00144, 8/26/24, that CFPB did not violate the Administration Procedure Act (APA) when it finalized the small business data collection rule (Section 1071) last March. Section 1071 requires banks that make at least 100 small business loans a year to collect and report certain data about the small business borrower, application information, and loan terms. In his decision, Judge Crane wrote: “It may well be that the Final Rule proves ill-advised as a policy matter, but that possibility does not itself make the Final Rule unlawful under the APA.”
I am certainly disappointed with the decision. WBA, and the industry as whole, continue to be gravely concerned over the cost of implementing the rule and most importantly of the privacy concerns of our small business community borrowers. It is expected that the plaintiffs will appeal the decision.
As a result of the decision, WBA will continue our efforts on the federal level to persuade our congressional delegation of necessary changes. Last summer WBA worked to encourage our Wisconsin congressional delegation to pass Congressional Review Act (CRA) resolutions in both the U.S. House and Senate to disapprove the Section 1071 rule. Under the CRA, if Congress enacts a joint resolution of disapproval, a rule promulgated by an agency does not take effect. Unfortunately, President Biden vetoed the joint resolution of disapproval, and the Senate fell short in its vote with the necessary two-thirds vote to overturn the veto. But our fight continues.
WBA also plans to once again communicate industry concerns directly with CFPB staff in our upcoming fall Washington, D.C. Regulatory Trip where myself, and a dozen Wisconsin bankers, will meet directly with CFPB and other federal banking agencies to express specific regulatory concerns and advocate against excessive regulatory burden.
While WBA continues to fight implementation of Section 1071, CFPB continues to work towards implementation. CFPB previously issued an interim final rule to extend mandatory compliance dates given the court case mentioned above and has recently opened a beta platform for Section 1071 data collection.
Being mindful of the possibility of having to implement a rule as robust as Section 1071, WBA has provided Section 1071 training in past WBA Compliance Forums and through past webinars. Past toolkit materials will be reposted shortly to the WBA Compliance Resources page given the recent court decision. Additionally, WBA will be hosting a Section 1071 workshop, Friday, October 18 in a hybrid format. To further assist with implementing the rule as cost effectively as possible, WBA will continue to create other educational Section 1071 resources.
